| Platinum | Five Guys |
| Gold | Sara's |
| Silver | Bro Mans Sammiches |
| Bronze | Rosco's Sports Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | BigBar |
| Top Pick | Bro-Man's Sammiches |
| Top Pick | Max & Erma's |
| Top Pick | Pittsburgh Inn |
| Top Pick | Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Erie |
| Top Pick | The Pittsburgh Inn |