| Platinum | Ricardo's Restaurant |
| Gold | The Cork 1794 |
| Silver | Colao's Ristorante |
| Bronze | Oliver's Rooftop |
| Top Pick | Bay House |
| Top Pick | Bayfront Grille |
| Top Pick | BigBar |
| Top Pick | Cloud 9 Wine Bar & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Erie Fine Dining |
| Top Pick | Fine Restaurant & Bar |