| Platinum | Odis 12 Bar & Grille |
| Gold | Chippers Tavern |
| Silver | The Park Tavern |
| Bronze | Rosco's Sports Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Maria's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Presque Isle Pizza |
| Top Pick | Scooters |
| Top Pick | Six Pack House of Beer |
| Top Pick | The Zukor Club |
| Top Pick | Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |