| Platinum | Les Crago Jewelers |
| Gold | Ralph Miller Jewelers & Gallery |
| Silver | Fast Fix Jewelry and Watch Repairs |
| Bronze | Lake Life Gift Shop |
| Top Pick | Aleks Cher Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Breakiron Jewelers |
| Top Pick | Dempsey & Baxter |
| Top Pick | Erie Gold Exchange |
| Top Pick | Glass Growers Gallery |