| Platinum | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Stanganelli's |
| Silver | Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Ricardo's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Butch's Place |
| Top Pick | C&G's |
| Top Pick | Colao's Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Lakeshore Theresa's Deli |
| Top Pick | Serafini's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Skippereno's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |