| Platinum | Syd's place |
| Gold | Chippers Seafood & Southern Fusion |
| Silver | Red Lobster |
| Bronze | The Warf |
| Top Pick | Butch's Place |
| Top Pick | SAMURAI kitchen + sushi |
| Top Pick | Storming Crab |
| Top Pick | The Pittsburgh Inn |
| Top Pick | The Skunk & Goat Tavern |
| Top Pick | The Ugly Tuna |