| Platinum | Buzz n B's Aquarium & Pet Shop |
| Gold | Pet Supplies Plus |
| Silver | Tractor Supply Co |
| Bronze | PetSmart |
| Top Pick | Erie Crawford Cooperative |
| Top Pick | Horstman & Son's Country Store |
| Top Pick | Mud Puppies Self Service Dog Wash |
| Top Pick | Nickel Plate Mills |
| Top Pick | Petco |