| Platinum | One-Eighty Consignment & Thrift |
| Gold | Cobb's Second Time Around Thrift Shop |
| Silver | Cha Cha's Thrift Store |
| Bronze | The Sassy Peacock & Peacock Joe's |
| Top Pick | Bayfront Entertainment |
| Top Pick | Erie City Mission |
| Top Pick | Goodwill Stores |
| Top Pick | The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center |
| Top Pick | Thrifter Heaven |