| Platinum | Aldi |
| Gold | Wegmans |
| Silver | Bello's Shur Fine Food Mart |
| Bronze | Erie Food Co-op |
| Top Pick | Giant Eagle |
| Top Pick | Kelly's Korner Market |
| Top Pick | Larry's Central Market |
| Top Pick | Walmart |
| Top Pick | West Ridge Road Store |
| Top Pick | Whole Foods Co-Op & Cafe |