| Platinum | Smileys Ice Cream |
| Gold | Northern Scoop |
| Gold | The Straw Hat Sundae Shop |
| Silver | Sara's |
| Bronze | Whippy Dip |
| Top Pick | Connie's Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Creamland Drive-In |
| Top Pick | Denny's Ice Cream Stand |
| Top Pick | Good Times Grill & Chill |
| Top Pick | Romolo Chocolates |