| Nominate Nominated! | Alfee's Pizza & Sub Shop |
| Nominate Nominated! | Barbato's |
| Nominate Nominated! | BigBar |
| Nominate Nominated! | Blaze Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Coach's Sports Bar & Grill |
| Nominate Nominated! | Colony Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Donatos Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Eric Broffman |
| Nominate Nominated! | Firestones |
| Nominate Nominated! | Hungry Howie's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Ippa Pizza Truck |
| Nominate Nominated! | John's Wildwood Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Lakeshore Theresa's Deli |
| Nominate Nominated! | Little Caesars |
| Nominate Nominated! | Marco's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Maria's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | My Dad's Pizza & Deli |
| Nominate Nominated! | Passalinqua Pizzaera |
| Nominate Nominated! | Patti's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Hut |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Pete's Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Porky'spizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Presque Isle Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Erie |
| Nominate Nominated! | Sabo's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Skippereno's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Stevo's Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Sticks & Bricks |
| Nominate Nominated! | Sticks and Bricks Wood Fire Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | U Pick 6 Public House |
| Nominate Nominated! | U Pick 6 Tap House |
| Nominate Nominated! | Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Vintage Wood Fire Restaurant and Catering |
| Nominate Nominated! | Virgil's Plate |
| Nominate Nominated! | Waterford Pizza and More |
| Nominate Nominated! | Yonkers Pizzeria |