| Platinum | Panera Bread |
| Gold | Lil Wagon |
| Silver | Tater Tater |
| Bronze | The Boardroom |
| Top Pick | Dinner Is Served By Lisa |
| Top Pick | Erie Food Co-op |
| Top Pick | Max & Erma's |
| Top Pick | SAMURAI kitchen + sushi |
| Top Pick | The Brewerie at Union Station |
| Top Pick | The Pittsburgh Inn |