| Platinum | Romolo Chocolates |
| Gold | Pulakos Chocolates |
| Silver | Stefanelli's Candies |
| Bronze | Five Below |
| Top Pick | Edinboro Chocolaterie |
| Top Pick | Julie's Sweet Treats |
| Top Pick | Julies Chocolates |
| Top Pick | Lake Erie Candy Company |
| Top Pick | Peggy Grays |
| Top Pick | Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory |