| Platinum | Erie Federal Credit Union |
| Gold | Corry Federal Credit Union |
| Silver | Widget Financial |
| Bronze | Americo Federal Credit Union |
| Top Pick | Bliley Federal Credit Union |
| Top Pick | Erie City Employee Federal Credit Union |
| Top Pick | North East Welch Federal Credit Union |
| Top Pick | St Vincent Erie Federal Credit Union |
| Top Pick | Tendto Credit Union |