| Platinum | Federal Hill Smokehouse |
| Gold | Vintage Wood Fire Restaurant and Catering |
| Silver | Bradys Chuckwagon |
| Silver | CamaradERIE BBQ |
| Bronze | Underdog BBQ |
| Top Pick | Holy Smokes Barbecue |
| Top Pick | Que Abides |
| Top Pick | Smoke N Fire |
| Top Pick | Smokey Bones Erie |
| Top Pick | Texas Roadhouse |
