| Platinum | Art's Bakery |
| Gold | Ye Ole Sweet Shoppe |
| Silver | Sundae |
| Bronze | Brew Ha Ha |
| Top Pick | Franks Farmer Market |
| Top Pick | Giant Eagle |
| Top Pick | Luminary Distilling, Fuhrman's Bakery, Eatery |
| Top Pick | Millie's Morsels |
| Top Pick | Romolo Chocolates |
| Top Pick | Sontheimer's Country Bakery |