| Platinum | Virgil's Plate |
| Gold | Maria's Pizza |
| Silver | Colony Pizza |
| Bronze | Porky'spizzeria |
| Top Pick | BigBar |
| Top Pick | John's Wildwood Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lakeshore Theresa's Deli |
| Top Pick | Presque Isle Pizza |
| Top Pick | Waterford Pizza and More |
| Top Pick | Yonkers Pizzeria |