| Platinum | Picasso's |
| Gold | Maria's Pizza |
| Silver | Whole Darn Thing |
| Bronze | Wegmans Sub Shop |
| Top Pick | Big Cheese Food Truck |
| Top Pick | Bro Mans Sammiches |
| Top Pick | Bro-Man's Sammiches |
| Top Pick | Jersey Mike's Subs |
| Top Pick | Panera Bread |
| Top Pick | Presque Isle Pizza |